John Joseph Adams
|Posted on Wednesday, June 29, 2005 - 06:53 pm: |
Slush Writer Appreciation Month continues! Today, I posted a new interview with Brian Bieniowski, who reads slush for ASIMOV'S.
In this excerpt, Mr. Bieniowski discusses what's wrong with media SF:
It's funny how so many reviews by SF fans of sci-fi films take this tone: "If only film could portray the magnitude and majesty of written Speculative Fiction! Philip K. Dick is rolling in his grave and weeping in heaven! Why can't we get the attention and due we deserve?"
My first thought is always that these people take blockbuster movies a little too seriously. And I'm seriously skeptical of the thought that a few honest-to-god serious SF movies would magically change the public's opinion of the genre, in print or media. I really don't think John Q. Public gives much of a care to think about these cultural debates at all. It's always sci-fi people discussing it. Everybody else says, "I enjoyed reading Dune, but Star Wars really wasn't my thing." Or vice versa. Or maybe you're like me and enjoy both for what they are.
Thus, why worry what the sociological effects of Star Wars, or whatever you choose, are? This hunting and gathering in so many articles for a widespread legitimacy for SF in media seems unnecessary and impotent, like kids on a playground yelling "one day you'll see how important we are!" as they struggle with their wedgies.